Back to Blog
Direct MailPostcards

EDDM vs. Targeted Direct Mail: Which One Fits Your Business?

Justin Daly November 17, 2026 7 min read

Two businesses in Thousand Oaks mailed postcards the same week.

The new pizza place blanketed every home within a few miles of its door. No list. No names. Every mailbox on the routes it picked got a card.

The med spa across town mailed a few hundred past clients and lapsed customers — people who had already walked through its door once. Nobody else.

Both used postcards. Both did it right. They just weren't selling the same thing to the same people.

That's the whole EDDM vs. targeted mail question, really: are you trying to reach everyone near you, or the right someone?

Here's how each one works, what each one costs, and how to tell which one your business actually needs.

The Short Answer

EDDM — Every Door Direct Mail, a U.S. Postal Service program — puts your postcard in every mailbox on the carrier routes you choose. No mailing list. No names or addresses printed on the pieces.

Targeted direct mail goes to a list: your own customers, or a list built around the demographics and geography you pick. Every card lands in front of someone chosen on purpose.

And the print side is the same either way: postcards at Where2Print start at $21.58, with professional design available as a $100 add-on if you don't have artwork ready.

So the real decision isn't the postcard. It's the audience.

How EDDM Works

EDDM is built for saturation.

  • You pick postal carrier routes — the neighborhoods you want to cover
  • USPS delivers one piece to every address on those routes
  • There's no mailing list to buy, rent, or clean up
  • The pieces are larger-format flats — bigger than a standard postcard, with room to be seen in the stack
  • Postage is charged per piece, at rates set by USPS

Because nothing is addressed to a specific person, there's no list work at all. You choose the map. The mail follows it.

That makes EDDM the natural fit when your customer is simply "everyone who lives near me" — which, for a lot of local businesses, is exactly the truth.

How Targeted Direct Mail Works

Targeted mail starts with people, not routes.

  • You mail your own customer list — past buyers, past clients, your house file
  • Or you work from a purchased or rented list, selected by geography and demographics: homeowners, income ranges, ages, business types
  • Pieces run in standard postcard sizes
  • You choose the postage class — First-Class Mail or Marketing Mail — based on timing and budget

Every card costs something to send, so targeted mail is about not wasting any of them. If only one household in ten on a route could ever buy from you, targeted mail lets you skip the other nine.

The Two, Side by Side

Audience

  • EDDM: every address on the routes you select
  • Targeted: a specific list of people or businesses

Mailing list

  • EDDM: none — that's the point
  • Targeted: required — yours, or one built for you

Piece size

  • EDDM: larger flat formats
  • Targeted: standard postcard sizes

Postage

  • EDDM: per piece, set by USPS
  • Targeted: depends on the class you choose — First-Class or Marketing Mail

Best at

  • EDDM: blanketing a service area or neighborhood
  • Targeted: reaching a defined audience without paying to mail everyone else

What It Costs

The print is the easy part to price, so let's price it: postcards start at $21.58 at Where2Print, and if you need the card designed, that's a flat $100 add-on.

Postage is the variable, and it works differently for each:

  • EDDM: postage is per piece, set by USPS. No list cost on top — the route is the list.
  • Targeted: postage depends on the class you send, and if you're not mailing your own customers, there's a list cost to build or rent the audience.

One honest note: the cheapest campaign on paper isn't always the cheapest one that works. Mailing every door on a route is wasted money if your buyer is one specific kind of household. Mailing a tight list is wasted money if everyone within three miles is a fair prospect and you only reached a fraction of them.

The right comparison isn't cost per piece. It's cost per customer who could actually walk in.

Pro Tip from a Local Print Expert: Start with your map, not your mail piece. Draw the area you'd drive to for a good job — here in the Conejo Valley, that might be Thousand Oaks and Newbury Park but not over the grade, or Westlake Village but not down into LA. If that whole map is your market, EDDM fits. If your real market is a type of person scattered across that map, go targeted.

When EDDM Wins

Choose EDDM when your offer is for everyone nearby:

  • Grand openings — the whole neighborhood needs to know you exist
  • Restaurants and retail — your customers live within a few miles, full stop
  • Home services — roofers, plumbers, landscapers, house cleaners: if they own a home in your service area, they're a prospect
  • Service-area businesses — anyone whose market is a map, not a demographic

If you'd happily take every household on the route as a customer, paying to reach all of them isn't waste. It's coverage.

When Targeted Mail Wins

Choose targeted when your audience is specific:

  • Past customers — the strongest list there is; these people already know you
  • A defined demographic — a certain homeowner profile, income band, or age range
  • B2B — businesses aren't on residential routes; a list gets you to the right companies and titles
  • High-value offers — when one sale is worth a lot, a smaller, sharper list beats a bigger, blunter one

If you can describe your customer in a sentence, a list can probably find them. That's when targeted earns its keep.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does EDDM stand for?

Every Door Direct Mail. It's a U.S. Postal Service program that delivers your mail piece to every address on the carrier routes you select — no mailing list required.

Do I need a mailing list for EDDM?

No. That's the main difference. You choose routes on a map, and every address on those routes receives your piece. Targeted direct mail is the option that uses a list — your own customers, or one selected by demographics and geography.

Which is cheaper, EDDM or targeted mail?

It depends on your audience. EDDM has no list cost and postage is per piece at USPS rates; targeted mail adds list costs if you don't have your own list, and postage varies by the class you choose. The better question is which one reaches your actual customers without paying to mail people who will never buy.

What size are EDDM postcards?

EDDM uses larger flat mail sizes — bigger than a standard postcard. Targeted mail can run in standard postcard sizes. Either way, postcards at Where2Print start at $21.58, and we can help you pick the size that fits the program you're sending.

Can I mail my own customer list?

Yes — that's targeted direct mail, and your own customer list is usually the best-performing audience a business has. Past customers already know you; a postcard is often all it takes to bring them back.

Talk to Where2Print About Your Mailing

Tell us who you're trying to reach, and we'll tell you which route gets you there — including if the honest answer is the simpler one.

Call Where2Print at 866.301.2880 or get a quick quote, and we'll map it out with you.

Mailing for an event instead of a neighborhood? Our trade show booth cost guide breaks down what a booth actually runs in 2026.

Ready to Order?

Start your postcards now: open the postcard builder, pick your size and quantity, and see your price as you build it.

Open the Postcard Builder